The film review you didn't need about the movie you didn't need which answered questions you weren't curious about

You can probably guess my unbiased opinion of the movie based on the title of this article, but if not I'll just say it: Solo is unnecessary and pointless. I've waited a couple of weeks after its release to write a review-- not because I do not want to ruin your experience with spoilers. For the same reason I kept having to remind myself over and over a Star Wars movie was coming out in months/days/hours. I kept forgetting. It is not a bad movie; it is fun and at times funny. But it should not exist.

When Disney bought Lucasfilm several years ago, I screamed. New Star Wars films! I loved The Force Awakens, Rogue One, and The Last Jedi. They had vision, unexpected developments, and characters I loved and cared for. It was recently announced that two new Star Wars trilogies are in development, plus a Boba Fett spin-off. For Solo, Disney thought one of the most beloved characters in film history, and my all-time favorite film character, needed a back story.


The film's original directors were fired, necessitating re-shoots with new director Ron Howard, exploding the movie's budget to reportedly $250 million. After two weeks, it's grossed $155 million-- pretty great for most summer blockbusters released on Memorial Day weekend; pretty lousy for a Star Wars movie (the previous three each made over $1B). So far this year it's sandwiched between A Quiet Place (haven't seen it but I've heard great things) and Ready Player One (pretty lousy).

Now there are probably lots of factors for this showing, mostly Star Wars fatigue. Check out this timeline:
1977: A New Hope
1980: The Empire Strikes Back
1983: Return of the Jedi
1999: The Phantom Menace
2002: Attack of the Clones
2005: Revenge of the Sith
2015: The Force Awakens
2016: Rogue One
2017: The Last Jedi
2018: (six months later): Solo
2019: Episode IX

There were four movies in the first 22 years of this franchise. There have been four movies in the last 3 1/2 years. Not to mention TV spinoffs and video games. But as I said, the previous three movies made a billion dollars, and Marvel has consistently made $$$ with its packed release schedule.

Even a Star Wars movie still must have characters we care about and want to spend time with. Aside from Donald Glover's Lando impression (spot on), it's not happening here. In a movie about Han Solo, the coolest, funniest movie personality ever. Unreal.

So if you are not a Star Wars geek you will probably enjoy Solo. What I didn't like about it was all the call-backs to fans. Ready Player One did this too. A few pop culture references are ok-- the Deadpool movies are great at this-- but Solo is all call-backs. Two and a half hours of them. All of them unnecessary. We find out:

  • where Han's blaster comes from
  • where Chewie's nickname comes from
  • where Han's last name comes from (WHAT??)
  • where Lando's Return of the Jedi costume from Jabba's palace comes from
  • Han doesn't just understand the Wookie language-- he actually growls (??) it?
  • Han's dice. This was ok in The Last Jedi because it was just a glance; but here we see the dice at least three times
  • Han really does shoot first (that's a spoiler so I won't ruin it for you)
  • The Kessel Run really was accomplished in 12 parsecs, not as Han is obviously boasting/exaggerating in A New Hope-- and no one is impressed. This is a key element of his character that Solo just erases

And there's one point where Han is betrayed, and the guy says, "I told you earlier to trust no one." He actually says that line-- a standard cliche from any action movie with a character twist. Lazy. And people keep telling us how great a pilot Han Solo is-- after he has told us over and over that he wants to be a great pilot. Can't we just judge it for ourselves? Actually the movie makes it pretty clear that the Millennium Falcon does the difficult piloting work itself. But in the movies made forty years ago and Episodes VII and VIII it's Han or Rey who make the Falcon great. My head hurts.

If you are curious about Han Solo, watch A New Hope and The Empire Strikes Back. Watch The Force Awakens. He is a supporting character in this universe-- one who has a major change of heart and becomes the hero he once thought were useless do-gooders. The chemistry between Harrison Ford and Carrie Fisher and Mark Hamill is just electric, unlike the chemistry between characters in Solo. They are good actors; the material doesn't measure up.

Just unnecessary.